My review of Avatar

December 30th, 2009

I give Avatar 3 out of 5 stars. The visual effects are impressive, but the story is only adequate. If you haven't seen it yet, buy a ticket and you'll enjoy this movie (especially in 3D IMAX). But it's not one you'll be talking about years from now. Read on for more details (no major spoilers)…

Other than a brief opening sequence, all the movie takes place on the alien world Pandora. Pandora's blue humanoid aliens are the Na'vi. Despite its Earth-like appearance, humans require breathing masks to operate outside the main base, run by a nameless corporation. The corporation's scientific division has created Na'vi bodies which can be controlled by humans. When linked into these bodies, the human drivers experience the world as Na'vi, and can walk around outside the base without the need for breathing masks. The main character, Sully, is a paraplegic ex-marine who unexpectedly gets a chance to run one of the avatars. All previous avatar operators are scientists with years of training, so there is initial animosity between Sully and the scientists on the base. Sully eventually gets caught between the nameless corporation who runs the base to mine a very rare & expensive mineral, and the Na'vi who have a deep spiritual connection to their world. The nameless corporation has tried to entice them with new technology, but the Na'vi are happy with their natural lifestyle. The company has well-equipped security division comprised mostly of ex-military, led by a trigger-happy Colonel. It doesn't take long for lop-sided confrontations between the security division and the Na'vi. Further complicating things is a romance that develops between Sully and a Na'vi woman.

This noble-savages vs evil-corporation plot is just barely adequate. About half-way through the movie, you will probably be able to predict the overall plot for the remainder of the movie. Cameron does have a few sci-fi twists on how the Na'vi are linked to their environment, but nothing that exceptional.

The visuals, on the other hand, are spectacular. It's hard to believe that the vast majority of Pandora's lush scenery and alien creatures are computer generated. In the last few years Cameron has been doing documentary films, and the first half of the film feels like a nicely done nature documentary. The Na'vi are equally impressive on-screen. Cameron filmed actors playing Na'vi roles, then used motion captured from these performances to animate the computer-generated Na'vi you see on screen. Previous to the Na'vi, the best computer generated character was Gollum from the Lord of the Rings movie trilogy. The Na'vi are definitely a notch above Gollum. I've seen some reviewers who say that Cameron has finally conquered the uncanny valley with the Na'vi, but that may be a bit too generous. Although humanoid, the Na'vi are still not human, so it's hard to know if Cameron could really have pulled off an entirely believable computer generated human. Regardless, the Na'vi as humanoid aliens are totally believable and never strike a false note.

Comparing Avatar with Cameron's other movies, it feels like a cross between his sci-fi adventure The Abyss, and his romantic drama Titanic.  The battles in the last 30 minutes of Avatar are excellent, but The Abyss was a white-knuckle ride virtually the entire movie.  On a pure romantic drama basis, Avatar is not as good as Titanic which didn't have any sci-fi or adventure distractions.

Despite my complaints about the plot, the visuals make up for what the plot is lacking. If you haven't seen Avatar yet, go buy a ticket this weekend. You won't regret it.

LED traffic lights don't melt snow

December 25th, 2009

LED traffic lights have an overlooked problem in the snow, compared to traditional incandescent bulbs — they don't melt the snow.  This has led to some accidents where snow piled up against the traffic lights.  Old-school incandescent bulbs are inefficient and produce heat which melts the snow.  But new LED lights produce very little heat, and so the snow blocks the lights.

Pop-up Legos

December 6th, 2009

Who knew you could use 4500 Legos to build a box that opens into a pop-up Japanese temple ?  Fast forward about 30 seconds to get to the part where he opens to reveal the pop-up.  Stay with the video for close-ups of the mechanism.

Flat Irons sunrise panorama

November 30th, 2009

Last June I got up early to take sunrise pictures of the Flat Irons, including this panorama. The initial view looks west from Chatauqua. (Google maps).

Flat Irons sunrise, last June

November 29th, 2009

Finally got around to uploading some picture of the Flat Irons at sunrise. I took these last June.

Panorama at Silver Lake, NH

October 24th, 2009

In September we visited New Hampshire to attend the wedding of some of our friends. We stayed in their family's cabin on Silver Lake. The pano below is from the dock on the lake. The center of the view is looking west. (Google maps).

First snow

October 10th, 2009

This year's first significant snow arrived before all the leaves had fallen. This morning we awoke to 3 or 4 inches. Picture is of the golf course from our deck.

FirstSnowfall2009

Which checkout line is faster?

September 29th, 2009

Dan Meyer writes about his research on  which line is faster at the store?  Awesome.  One quick tidbit is the minimum time for one person is about 50 seconds, but an average item adds about 3 seconds.  So it's faster to pick a line with up to 17 more items vs a line with one more person that has only one item.

The comments are interesting too, pointing out "invisible" effects like will the person use coupons, or want to buy a lotto ticket?  The commenters note that you could assign weighted probabilities, which leads to another interesting series of questions.  For example, based on probabilities suppose you have the following estimates to get to the head of each line:

Estimate based on
"invisible" factors
Best Avg Worst
Line 1 3 min 5 min 11 min
Line 2 4 min 6 min 10 min
Line 3 5 min 7 min 9 min

Now which line would you pick?  Line 3 is predictable, but Line 1 could finish really fast; or take a really long time.

netjeff.com hosting upgraded

September 27th, 2009

I just upgraded the hosting for netjeff.com.  If you see any issues, please add a comment to this post, or send email to jeff@netjeff.com, with a brief subject that includes the word "maps" ("maps" is spam backwards).

Longmont Airshow

September 9th, 2009

Just posted pictures from the Longmont Airshow in my gallery.